Cultural Identity of Kashmiri Pandits - Retrospect
and Prospect
by Prof. Som Shah
Kashmiri
Pandit Identity – a historical perspective
Within the Hindu fraternity, Kashmiri
Pandits (KPs) occupy a distinct and unique position because of a tumultuous
history and consequent evolution, including several aberrations and distortions.
At one point of time Kashmir was a great seat of learning and Kashmiri Hindus
produced intellectuals of all hues like philosophers, writers, poets, therapists
and historians. It would be out of place to list the achievements and
contributions that Kashmiri Brahmins made during some glorious periods of Hindu
rule and even during some phases of Muslim rule. On the spiritual side it
witnessed the onslaught of Buddhist wave together with rest of south and
south-east Asia, and eventually countered it through philosophic movement of a
distinct kind of Shaivism. However, all this was achieved through debates and
discussions as has been the normal practice in all oriental religions.
There is a common mistaken notion that among
Kashmiri Hindus there was no caste system and all Hindus are Brahmins. That may
be the situation as of now but historically Kashmir shared with rest of India
the same kind of caste system with its grotesque customs and practices. This was
the reason that most of the non-Brahmins initially opted for Buddhism during its
heyday and Kashmir at one point of time, before the start of Christian era, was
an important centre of Buddhist society. However, as in rest of India, Brahmin
revivalism brought an end to Buddhist sway over the populace in general.
Brahmins dominated the religious scenario
including the ruling hierarchy in the valley for several centuries. While on the
positive side they made considerable contribution to the intellectual,
philosophical and spiritual aspects of the society, on the negative side they
strictly enforced hereditary caste discrimination and a narrow-minded
exclusivism. This was one of the main reasons that made it easy for Islam to
enter the valley in the first instance and take over the administration and
eventually to convert the populace to that faith. Added to that an aggressive
proselytization by Muslim missionaries with strong support of ruling community
and several periods of forced conversion, almost the entire lot of non-Brahmins
embraced the Islamic faith. Even some of the Brahmins were also forcibly
converted, after their temples were desecrated and mosques built in their place.
However, such was the strong hold of the caste system that even after conversion
the Muslims retained the caste distinctions almost up to the present day and
usually intermarriages and social contacts across the caste lines were a taboo.
Thus the so called “Khandani” upper caste converts from Brahmins (Kauls,
Rainas Bhats, Choudhrys, Sheikhs) and Rajputs (Dars, Mirs, Rathers, Maliks,
Loans) would look down upon lower castes like Vaishs (Wanis) and Shudras
comprising a host of menial surnames.
What was left of Brahmins after these
conversions and waves of migration outside the valley, constituted a hard core
community of Pandits who managed to resist all the allurements, deprivation,
pressures, intimidation, harassment and even death threats. Understandably they
developed certain traits, both positive and negative, because of a persistent
fear and threat to dignity, property, honour and life. It is these traits that
have become a hallmark of their identity as distinct from that of Kashmiri
Muslims. Probably the only similarity was a common language and idiom. Language
is undoubtedly a strong binding force and constitutes the only factor that could
be classed as the so called “Kashmiriat” that has been branded as a
political slogan in recent years to be used and misused as the occasion demands.
But even in language, thanks to the imposition of an unnatural and
inappropriate Nastaliq script, a schism has developed between the two
communities. Other than the language, there is hardly anything common between
the two communities, except for nostalgia of dependence on each other and to
some extent tolerating each other. While personal equations and close man to man
contacts have always been there, but none of them were on the basis of any
cultural identity.
Kashmiri Pandits had a relatively peaceful
and secure time during the brief Sikh rule and about a century of Dogra rule.
This period generated a sense of euphoria in them that made them complacent,
though there were occasions when they should have been vary and watchful.
Communal riots of 1931 that is nowadays projected as a freedom struggle should
have been one such occasion. The complacency was gradually broken when
successive governments after independence started the process of discrimination
and the community was forced to seek avenues outside the state. The process of
migration that started as a trickle gradually became rapid and culminated in a
mass exodus as a result of planned intimidation at gun point.
Evolution
of customs and rituals
A common belief among most KPs is that
rituals and customs that were prevalent in the valley before mass exodus
constitute the KP culture and need to be preserved in totality to sustain a
cultural identity. This belief is primarily because of nostalgia following the
trauma of displacement and an attempt to snatch at straws to replicate a
situation as existed before the exodus. However, rituals and customs do not
constitute cultural identity since they keep on changing and evolving from time
to time. Culture is like a flowing river that receives input from different
directions through various tributaries including dirty drains. As long as it
keeps on flowing and receiving these inputs, it remains vibrant and fresh. When
it becomes static, it stagnates into a marsh. Kashmiri Pandit culture has never
stagnated in spite of various pressures, trials and tribulations. It has always
adjusted and accommodated according to the circumstances and situations. That
has been the secret of its survival.
Those who believe that rituals must be
retained in their entirety in order to sustain cultural identity would do well
to examine them in a historical perspective. There can be no better example than
the rituals associated with one of the main festivals of KP identity, the
Shivratri. These rituals and customs have undergone a total transformation
during last few centuries. At one point of time the celebrations, puja and rituals for this festival extended for forty days
commencing from Shiv Chaturdashi (fourteenth day of the dark fortnight of Magh)
to Phagum Ashtami (Tila Ashtami). In the course of time it got reduced to twenty
days and eventually to a few days. During the Afghan rule, a stupid governor
(there was a series of them) was told that Pandits invoked their secret powers
through puja during Shivratri and
fasting and refraining from non-vegetarian food. He ordered that they should be
forced to gambol during this period and to partake of non-vegetarian meals.
Accordingly the Pandits had to gambol with shells (hara), that was the prevalent currency, and this became a part of
the ritual that continues up to the present day in the valley. The Muslims were
asked to spy on their Pandit neighbours to ensure that they partook of
non-vegetarian food on the day following Shivratri and they made a point to
visit them and thus the name Salaam
was given to that day. The name Shivratri itself continues to be called Herath
(derived from Persian word Hairat,
meaning surprise), following the infamous order of Jabbar Khan (Jabbar Jendha)
to celebrate the festival in summer when a snow storm hit the valley. When Sikhs
invaded the valley on the invitation of KPs and drove out the Afghans, the
Pandits included Waghuru (Wahi Guru) puja one day prior to Shivratri as a mark of thanksgiving. Following
Dogra rule they included Ram Gud as
one of deities in the puja since Ram
was the Kul Devta of Dogra rulers. The rituals associated with this festival
have changed continuously depending on the exigencies of the situation and the
political climate. But Shivratri constitutes a basic festival of our cultural
identity. Most people may be aware that different families adopted varying riti
(customs) for every festival meaning thereby that these riti
hardly constitute a part of cultural identity.
The elderly generation who suffered the pangs
of displacement is nostalgic about most of the rituals that were prevalent
before the exodus. That accounts for their anxiety to hold on to them. The
younger generation, especially those born just before or after exodus, have no
such nostalgia and are generally confused about the fascination that the elders
have for something that appears silly to them.
No doubt, as time passes, most of these redundant rituals will die their
natural death, as has happened to several such customs in the past. If somebody
wants to have a peep into what our customs were a few centuries ago, he would do
well to observe them in Kashmiri Pandit families who migrated into various other
parts of India centuries before and have retained many of those traditions as
they existed at that point of time.
What
constitutes Kashmiri Pandit cultural identity
If rituals are not essential features of
cultural identity, then it is necessary to identify what constitutes a KP
identity. For that it is important to understand what has sustained them through
centuries of turmoil, torture, discrimination and intimidation. That alone
should constitute the foundation of a true identity. Culture is a combination of
several factors that have accumulated historically and become part of identity.
It may not be possible to list all these here but the more essential features
are briefly mentioned below:
Hindu
Ethos:
KPs have a distinct identity
primarily because they are a repository of Hindu ethos. Hinduism is a
philosophical doctrine and not a religion in the strict sense of that word. A
religion is dogmatic and has well defined and enforceable dos and don’ts.
Hinduism allows free scope for speculation and an open invitation to discover
divinity in whichever manner a person chooses. In this regard it is closer to
scientific ethos that allows an open mind to discover laws of nature. The two
have also a symbiotic relationship. While one aims at the ultimate in the
spiritual domain the focus of the other is the material plane. One sustains the
other and that is the reason there is no contradiction and confrontation between
science and religion in the Hindu context unlike religions of Middle Eastern
origin. KPs have a remarkable capacity for rationalization of any situation and
absorbing all contradictory opinions. This stems from their strong roots in
Hindu ethos. That also dissuades them from becoming dogmatic or fundamentalist.
They have resisted conversion primarily because they have an in born tendency to
reject a dogmatic belief. Talking about the Hindu ethos Beatrice Lamb, the
British author, has made the following telling comment:
“Indeed, one characteristic that all Hindus claim for Hinduism is an
all-embracing tolerance, its ability to encompass every path, finding a niche
for each in the vast scheme of things. From the point of view of certain
minority religions, this is precisely the difficulty. Any religion that does not
want to be encompassed, embraced and indeed absorbed and perhaps ultimately
transformed by Hinduism finds Hindu tolerance somewhat too demanding since it is
conditioned upon a basic acceptance of a Hindu view of life and Hinduism’s
peculiar genius for absorption.” While
it may not be possible to agree with him in all details, but basically he has
made the point that is characteristic of Hinduism in general and KPs in
particular.
Shiva-Shakti
cult:
While Kashmir was the fountainhead of a distinct philosophy of Shaivism,
it is also a fact that majority of KPs is unaware of its tenets and
significance. However, it has given birth to a special brand of deity worship
that is distinct from most Hindus. Shivratri or Watak Puja is distinct for KPs
and is observed in a specific manner quite unlike other Shaivite Hindus. Its
significance has various interpretations but they are primarily derived from
special Shiva-Shakti cult that is peculiar to KPs.
Shakti worship has also generated
identification of Ishat Devis (Kul Devis) whereby Goddess Durga has been
personified in various forms, only partly corresponding to the Nav Durga
concept. There are primarily three Ishat Devis namely the eighteen armed Sharika,
personifying protection, the four armed Raghinia personifying bounties and eight
armed Jwala depicting energy. All KPs have either one of them as their Kul Devi
that determines their mode of worship and eating habits. The seats of the three
are Chakreshwar (Hari Parbat), Tullamula (Kshir Bhawani) and Khrew (Jwaleshwari)
respectively. Apart from these, there are a large number of other shrines spread
over the length and breadth of the valley representing these Devis. These three
seats have a special significance in the spiritual life of every Kashmiri Pandit.
That is why immediately after exodus KPs replicated these seats in Jammu, Delhi
and elsewhere as they are the primary symbols of their cultural identity.
Language:
Language is always a strong binding force for any community and constitutes an
important element of cultural identity. Kashmiri language, though rich in idiom,
has suffered a checkered history, mainly because of the political turmoil and
suppression of the rulers. Primarily derived from Sanskrit and Prakrit and
retaining its grammatical nuances, it is flooded with words derived from other
sources, notably Persian. In this respect it has suffered the same fate as that
of Saxon English following Norman invasion. While the verbs are mostly derived
from Sanskrit, since the working class comprised local residents, most nouns and
adjectives are derived from Persian that was the language of the rulers.
However, there is one major difference between what happened to English language
through Norman influence and Kashmiri language after Persian domination. Since
the script of English and French was the same, the language got enriched with
words of French derivation without altering the scriptural nuances. In case of
Kashmiri its original script namely Sharda vanished since the rulers refrained
from using it and the Persian (Nastaliq) script did not suit the large number of
vowel sounds and even some consonants that are characteristic of Kashmiri. In
the process Kashmiri language lost its script and remained only a spoken
language. The Sharda script got relegated to writing of horoscopes and almanacs
by practicing Brahmins (who were referred to as Bhashya
Bhats meaning language knowing Pandits as against others who resorted to the
study of Persian and were referred to as karkuns),
in a traditional style not in Kashmiri but in classical Sanskrit. Because
of this Kashmiri language hardly acquired any written literature. Whatever
literature in Kashmiri existed up to the beginning of twentieth century
comprised no prose but only poetry carried through word of mouth.
While Kashmiri Muslims and Pandits speak the
same language, there is a difference in a large number of nouns and
pronunciation of some alphabets of Sanskrit origin. Muslims use nouns of Persian
origin while Pandits use those of Sanskrit origin. Words like ‘water’ would
be aab for a Muslim and poni
or woni (derived from Sanskrit warini)
for a Pandit. Likewise ‘sun’ would be aftab
and sirya and ‘dream’ would be khwab
and swapun respectively. Many Sanskrit derived sounds cannot be properly
pronounced by Muslims. The half sounds following a consonant that is common in
Sanskrit constitute some of them. For
example the half ‘r’ sound as in bror (cat)
or praran(waiting)would be pronounced as bior and piaran
respectively. Likewise there is a remarkable variation in the speech that can be
easily detected.
The imposition of Nastaliq script after 1947
by the government alienated Pandits from Kashmiri language as a result of which
they taught their children to speak in Hindi. A
large number of Pandit children had stopped considering Kashmiri language as
their mother tongue long before the mass exodus. This process was accentuated by
the increase of anti-national activity by some Muslim outfits in Kashmir and
Pandits identified Kashmiri language with them and Hindi as a symbol of
Indianness. Since medium of instruction was Hindi, Urdu or English, Kashmiri did
not fit anywhere in the educational system.
The imposition of Kashmiri as a compulsory language of study in Nastaliq
script up to the 5th standard was a stillborn exercise and even
Muslims did not take it seriously since they felt that it was of no value.
Poetry
and Music:
Kashmiri poetry, as has been mentioned earlier, was carried through word
of mouth up to the early part of twentieth century. The most popular among
Muslims as well as Hindus were the wakhs
of Lal Ded and Sahajanand alias Sheikh Nur-ud-Din. Both of them had a common
idiom and message of universal brotherhood and spirituality constituting an
amalgam of Shaivism and Sufism. While the former was known to be a Hindu, the
latter was supposedly born of converted Muslim parents though he never practiced
that religion and is being disowned by present day fundamentalist Muslims.
The wakhs
constitute an important cultural heritage of Kashmiri Pandits, especially those
of Lal Ded as they encompass the essence of Kashmir Shaivism in simple common
man’s language.
Another aspect of poetry that constitutes the
cultural identity of Kashmiri Pandits is the leela
that is sung in a lilting tune or to the beats of a tumbaknari. A leela is
always in praise of a deity depicting various attributes, or narrating events
from Bhagwat and tales from Puranas.
Perhaps one distinct cultural symbol of KPs
has been the wanwun that is
collectively sung on the occasion of various festivals notably yageopavit
and marriage. Most KPs are not aware that wanwun in its original form
was derived from classical music using three swars only. Muslims converted wanwun
into a folk song that they sing on festive occasions. Unfortunately the
classical form of wanwun has been
gradually dying down and even KPs have lately taken to the popular form sung by
Muslims. The former has a socio-religious significance that cannot be ignored.
Cuisine:
One of the aspects of Kashmiri Pandit culture that has found a national
acceptance and liking constitutes the special cuisine. The variety of dishes
cooked using different spices and the techniques employed have become so popular
that they constitute special menu of most five-star hotels of the country.
KP cuisine is totally different from that of Muslims. While the
non-vegetarian dishes are limited to five or six only, there is a wide variety
in vegetarian dishes. Of the former rogan josh and latter dum aloo
(listed usually in hotel menus as aloo dum)
are the most popular all over the country and abroad.
In the valley there was a tradition of drying
vegetables during summer months and using the same during winter. This was
primarily because no fresh vegetables were available in snow-clad winter. KPs,
notably ladies, have developed a special taste for these dried vegetables,
especially brinjals and gourds (lauki),
cooked in a specific manner. Nowadays due to better means of communication fresh
vegetables are available throughout winter months and Muslims in the valley
(especially in the cities) have generally discontinued this practice of drying
vegetables. What is however interesting is that the practice of drying continues
for commercial reasons as there is a demand
for these dried products from KPs living outside the valley following
exodus.
A discussion on cuisine would be incomplete
without mention of an essential component of KP table, haak, which is like a tanpura
in a musical concert. It has to be always there whether one cooks vegetarian or
non-vegetarian meals. In recent years it has become very popular with non-Kashmiris
as well, especially in Jammu.
Apparel:
The KP dress and jewelry have
suffered several historical vicissitudes as a result of which most of the
erstwhile apparel has become redundant. While at one point of time turban tied
in a particular fashion was the hallmark headgear of adult male Pandit and taranga
of a female, both have all but vanished. They are only used on the occasion of
marriage and that too in a highly modified form. The more common phiran as a kind of a gown has survived among men in some cases
especially those who still live in the valley or Jammu, where it is cold in
winter. The female phiran was almost abandoned following the reform movement led by
Kashyapa Bandhu in the thirties of the last century.
KP phiran
is different from that of Muslims and it is believed that this
differentiation was imposed during the rule of Zain-ul-abudin (Budshah). Though
he was known to be a just ruler and he imposed this order in good faith, it
reduced the Hindu population to a very small minority. The story goes that
during the rule of his predecessor, the infamous Sikandar (Butshikan), there was
a mass forcible conversion of Hindus. Many were murdered, and some migrated but
those who stayed back had perforce to accept Islam and change their name.
However, they were Hindus by heart and retained their Hindu practices and
identity. Thus everybody had two names, the Muslim name to be used for public
consumption and Hindu name at home. Since the dress was the same, it was not
possible to know whether one was a Hindu or a Muslim and the name was the only
identity. Budshah ordered that there would be no forcible conversions and in
order to ensure that he insisted that they dress differently. As a result all
those who were still Hindus at heart had perforce to adopt Muslim attire and in
due course of time became Muslims.
One of the important elements of the attire
of KP ladies that has not only survived but also become popular with non-Kashmiris
is the golden jewelry called ath, dejihoru
and ataharu. These are marital symbols comparable to mangal
sutra worn by Hindu ladies elsewhere in the country. They are the essential
elements of jewelry of a married lady.
Socio-religious
customs: There is a wide range of socio-religious customs and festivals
that are observed by KPs in a variety of ways. It is not possible to list them
but some of them have a religious connotation while there are several others
that have a historical or environmental relationship. Traditional festivals like
navreh, zang trai, pann and other similar festivals belong to the former category,
while shishur, gaad bata, khetchi
amawasya, nav sheen and the like belong to the latter category. Most of
these festivals fall during winter months which may be due to climatic
conditions in the valley. In addition there are traditional customs related to
marriages, child-births, deaths and other social events. Many of them also have
a religious rigmarole associated with them. Hardly anybody has an inkling of the
purpose behind many of these customs and even the supposed religious linkage is
dubious in most cases since there is no known source of the authority. Some of
these customs were not observed much before the mass exodus as they had become
redundant. After the exodus hardly anybody remembers them. But there are quite a
few that were religiously observed and continue to be observed even after
exodus.
Are
KPs losing their identity?
After the mass exodus the one apprehension
that is haunting the mind of every Kashmiri Pandit is about the danger of losing
his cultural identity. Surprisingly this apprehension was not there when KPs
were continuously being eased out from the mainstream in Kashmir for nearly half
a century after 1947 and made almost insignificant and irrelevant. There was a
continuous trickle of migration of younger generation for want of employment
avenues and the population was already reducing at a rapid rate.
It is also a fact that KPs living in Kashmir during that period had
almost accepted their second class citizen status as a fait
accompli. In most of the families the children had stopped speaking in
Kashmiri and they were afraid of donning a tilak
on the forehead or displaying any overt cultural identity. The lollipop of Kashmiriat was projected before them to remind them that they were a
part of a fraternity that was covertly Islamic. It would be necessary to analyze
why they were not anxious about the loss of their cultural identity at that
point of time.
Cultural identity is more a state of mind
than any tangible reality. Every human being has an emotional need to identify
himself first as an individual distinct from others and then as member of a
community or religion or country. This stems from the animal instinct of living
in a herd from which human beings evolved into a tribal culture. The social
evolution is proceeding at a rapid rate towards globalization whereby the
barriers of caste, creed, colour, race and geography are rapidly disintegrating.
Cultural identities are likely to get eroded in all communities irrespective of
geographical location or dislocation. But
that would be a futuristic scenario and some people who cannot reconcile with
such a rapid change would even label it as an improbable philosophical doctrine.
Until the day we head towards that status there is a strong instinctive need to
have an identity, since it provides a sense of security. In spite of all threats
to KP identity before exodus, they refused to acknowledge it since all symbols
of cultural identity were in place. The only time when they became slightly
apprehensive was in 1986 when several temples were desecrated. But after the
trauma of dislocation they suddenly found that they had lost all the symbols of
their identity, including their homes and hearths, and were practically like
straws in a wind.
Cultural identity is sustained through
symbolism with which people identify themselves. Since all these symbols were in
the valley the KPs suffered traumatic crisis of confidence following exodus.
Forced migration always generates a sense of rootless existence and consequently
an alarming fear of losing identity and getting lost in the mayhem of an alien
society. As a reaction KPs started building replicas of shrines at a frantic
pace almost everywhere, where they moved in sizable numbers. Moreover, they
started making noises as they had never done before through media. Such has been
the cacophony of these press statements coming from various kinds of outfits and
individuals that it gives an impression that the community is totally confused
and divided. This is far from truth for at no point of time have the KPs been
thinking differently, including when they left Kashmir en masse without any
planning, though they would not admit it.
While exodus has caused immense physical,
emotional, economic and psychic damage to KPs, there has been a silver lining.
The fear of losing the identity has galvanized the society as never before. In
fact at no point of time was the danger of losing identity more acute than when
they were living in Kashmir between 1947 and 1989. They were practically being
eased out without a whimper. They were losing their cultural symbols and
identity was getting rapidly eroded. The younger generation was gradually
migrating. Those who were left behind had lost confidence and were acquiring a
psyche of servility. If the mass exodus had not taken place the cultural
identity would have been lost within a few decades without anybody in the
country or elsewhere becoming wiser about it.
The exodus has brought about two positive
fall outs. While on the one hand it has triggered a renaissance in the
community, on the other the country and the world at large has come to know
about this highly cultured and sophisticated community and the injustice meted
out to it. The renaissance has been in various forms and fields and has seeped
down to the grassroots. Those Kashmiri Pandit boys and girls who lived in
backwaters of far flung villages of the valley donned some of the premier
educational institutes in the country and abroad. The number of books,
magazines, journals and articles published in last twenty years by KPs is
phenomenal. The linkage of Kashmiri Pandit groups and organizations spread
throughout the world is such that each one knows exactly of what is happening
and where. This is no doubt also a result of boom in communication network that
has fortunately happened precisely at the same time and KPs have taken maximum
benefit from it. Above all the renaissance has generated a serious introspection
and brain-storming among KPs, a faculty that they had totally forgotten when
they were in the valley.
There appears to be no danger about the loss
of cultural identity of KPs following dislocation. Apprehension of the loss
itself generates a consciousness of what we are likely to lose and we tend to
protect it. With that consciousness almost half the battle is won. When we are
confronted with an alien culture we feel insecure and generate a tendency to
look deep into our roots. That is what happened to those who migrated to western
countries and attempted to teach their children to stick to certain cultural
symbols and practices including learning Kashmiri when back home in Kashmir our
children had stopped all these practices and even speaking that language.
How
can KPs sustain a cultural identity
While it would be a cynical attitude to
presume that KPs are in danger of losing their cultural identity, there is at
the same time no scope for complacency. The community needs to put their heads
together to see what can be done to ensure that we uphold the positive and
distinctive elements of our culture. It has also to be understood that some of
the aspects of our traditions have become redundant either due to passage of
time and changed circumstances or because of being away from the valley. There
are also several negative elements of our culture that we have acquired through
exigencies of history which need to be expunged. While
a lot needs to be done to protect and expand the scope of our cultural
traditions, only some of the more urgent requirements are suggested below:
Building
Institutions: KPs were very prompt in building shrines and ashrams of
prominent saints of Kashmir immediately after exodus. As mentioned earlier, this was a reaction to the loss
of symbols of cultural identity and was probably important at that point of time
to generate confidence and sense of security. However, there has been a laxity
in building institutions of learning and research in aspects of culture and
civilization of the community. For example Kashmir Shaivism, that constitutes a
flagship of Kashmiri Pandit culture, has been relegated to the oblivion of
obscurantism. Following Swami Lakshman Joo and a few other scholars, there has
been no institutional follow up. While many non-Kashmiri, including foreign
scholars, have published treatises on this subject, there has been hardly any
concerted contribution from scholars of Kashmir. When we talk of preserving our
cultural heritage, anybody can ask a question what we mean by it. Is there an
institution or authority that can answer this question? Is there an institution
that can interpret our traditions in a historical perspective and give meaning
to what our culture is all about? While there is a lot of breast beating about
our youngsters not upholding the cultural traditions, do we have any reasoning
to tell them why they should follow some practices dogmatically? Nostalgia alone
cannot sustain traditions and culture. They need to be interpreted in the idiom
of modern times. This can be done only by an institution of higher learning
specialized in these areas. For years we have been dreaming about resurrecting
Sharda University, but it continues to be a dream only.
Preserving
Kashmiri language: Preserving Kashmiri language is probably the greatest
challenge before the community because there are basic hurdles in it. A language
is primarily a medium of communication. Any language that provides scope for
communication with the widest coverage is bound to expand and proliferate and a
language that has a limited convas is bound to languish. In this context it
would be pertinent to remember the Indian experience. Following independence
there was a concerted effort to promote Hindi as the national language. When it
met with difficulties because of large number of regional languages that were
not ready to accept Hindi, there was a view that unless English was replaced,
Hindi could not become lingua franca. This view was expressed as the infamous remark of Ram
Manohar Lohia, “Let Hindi go to hell, abolish English”, that raised a lot of
furor. Naturally (and fortunately) the nation did not listen to him. At present
it is only because of the knowledge of English that India has become a software
and IT hub.
Kashmiri language is plodding with basic
disabilities in the absence of well established script and lack of literature in
prose. Editors of some community journals are doing a commendable job by
publishing Kashmiri section in Devnagari script with some diacritical marks that
is tending to become a suitable script for Kashmiri language. But that alone is
not enough. There is need to use other methods to popularize the language. The
written word is not as popular and powerful nowadays as the verbal communication
and there is a need to make maximum use of IT to proliferate the language
through circulation of CDs and opening websites bearing interesting material in
Kashmiri. It is only possible to do so in an organized fashion and our numerous
outfits would do well to pool their resources in this direction.
Conclusion
The
apprehension about the loss of cultural identity may help us to be cautious and
pool our resources to rejuvenate the community. However, there is very little
likelihood of KPs losing their identity. It is a myth that dislocation causes
loss of identity. Historical evidence goes to prove that all dislocated
communities are more conscious of their identity than settled communities. The
examples of Jews and Parsees, who retained their identities for centuries in
exile, are there to indicate that it is not the geography but the cultural
strength and determination of the community that sustains an identity. There is
no reason to believe that KPs do not fall in that category.
His shrine was burnt down by fundamentalist Muslims from Pakistan during
nineties of the last century.
Source: Vitasta
|