Operation Gibraltar
and the
Indo-Pak War of 1965
By J.L. Tiku
“Ayub Khan may have a lot
to answer for authorizing Kashmir Operation, but in agreeing to ceasefire he
acted with...realism....patriotism...., though he had to pay a terrible price in
personal term” Altaf Gauhar
Probably, the successful encounter of the Pakistan army with Indian forces in the Rann of Kutch area had reinforced
Ayub Khan’s rising faith in the military superiority of his forces. The Rann of
Kutch conflict was a low cost test of Indian will & capabilities. Ayub khan in
his autobiography Friends Not Masters published in 1967 had left the
important event of the 1965 war untouched intentionally. Now his son Gauhar Ayub
Khan is trying to fill this gap in his reported forthcoming book. The book may
be an attempt to salvage the lost position of his father Field Marshal
Ayub Khan as President of Pakistan after 1965 debacle.
Rann of Kutch was one of the
areas left undemarcated by Radcliffe award during partition. Pakistan laid claim
to whole of Rann, contrary to India’s position. The clash started between border
police force and soon involved the armed forces of both sides. Pakistan did make
local gains, it seems they were prepared for the battle. India didn’t want to
engage extensively in the sticky area thinking it may have been Pakistan’s
diversionary tactics. The Rann of Kutch operation also bolstered Pakistan
official General Musa’s morale. His assessment of the inherent strength
of army rose in tandem to Ayub Khan’s perception on the subject.
Pakistan’s army was
persuaded to produce a plan for a bolder course of action. The task was
entrusted to Maj. Gen. Akhtar Hussain Malik, the General Officer
Commanding, 12th Division, who was responsible for the defence of Pak Occupied
Kashmir. The plan reflected his outlook and character - supposedly bold and
imaginative. Thus was Operation Gibraltar born.
Highly trained
30,000 strong non-Kashmiri guerilla force labeled Gibraltar
Forces was to be raised at Murree under the charge of Maj. Gen.
Akhtar Hussain Malik. The Gibraltar Forces bearing romantic names
comprised of ten forces. These would be infiltrating whole of Jammu & Kashmir
for mobilising mass scale uprising against India. Then the Pakistan army would
march in to protect the ‘revolutionaries’.
The decision for
Operation Gibraltar was primarily based on three important premises. It was
assumed that widespread support existed within Kashmir to make a guerilla
campaign a success. It was considered unlikely that as a consequence of this
action India would be inclined to attempt a large-scale military offensive
against Pak Occupied Kashmir territory. Lastly the possibility of India
crossing the international border either in then East or West Pakistan was ruled
out.
The several groups of
Gibraltar Forces that infiltrated into Kashmir were: Salaudin force
headed for Srinagar and Valley; Ghaznavi force operated in
Mendhar-Rajouri; Tariq force was to strike Dras and Kargil; Babbar
force Bhimber, Kalidhar; Qasim force Bandipora; Khalid force
Qazinag; Nasrat force Tithwal area. The operation was launched as
hurriedly as it had been conceived. It was not gradual enough to give it the
character of an internal uprising.
Whereas it was true that
goodwill for Pakistan existed in some pockets of Kashmir, it was unrealistic to
expect that this feeling of resentment against India could be mobilized all over
Jammu & Kashmir and thereby make the execution of large-scale operation within
Indian borders possible. They were not successful in establishing the necessary
rapport with local populace. Few of them were turned over or revealed to the
Indian army. With their self styled liberators and ‘freedom fighters’ who apart
from doing some damage to public property and inflicting much suffering on the
people by burning their homes got nowhere close to capturing the Srinagar Radio
Station for their historic broadcast on 9lh August proclaiming that war of
liberation was on.
When faced with a rapidly
escalating situation, which endangered India’s position in Kashmir, army
persuaded to retaliate in an area in Pak Occupied Kashmir, which would be
strategically important. The Haji Pir salient, which provided Pakistan with a
link between the northern and southern sectors of Pak Occupied Kashmir, was a
natural region, which fitted this pattern. Also, it had become important gateway
for infiltrators and had to be closed. On 27th August the Indian army launched a
strong attack on POK positions in the area, which were relatively lightly held,
and by 28th August we were in control of strategic territory to cut the line of
communication between Muzaffarabad, the capital of POK and Kotli, a major town
in the southern POK. On 10th September Indian force advancing from Poonch
completed the control of Uri-Poonch link, thus straightening the bulge.
Pakistan retaliatedin
vulnerable area of Chamb-Akhnur It is the only sector along the ceasefire line (LoC)
where tanks could be used effectively during, offensive. Pakistan ordered its
infantry division located South of Lahore to move to the Chamb area. Initially
the attack was to be carried out by Maj. Gen. Akhtar Hussain Mulik of 12th
Division. As formations of Pakistan's 12th division moved swiftly towards Akhnur,
India was faced with a difficult military situation. The capture of Akhnur by
Pakistan would provide them a base, seriously threaten the lines of
communication between India and the Kashmir valley and it could result in the
loss of a large portion of the Indian army in northern and central Kashmir.
Indian was left with little
choice but to remove this threat to the security of their vital strategic area.
Rather than confining the contest to Pak occupied Kashmir, it was decided to
widen the area of conflict to then West Pakistan. Operation Riddle was
code word for all out attack on West Pakistan. The plan was prepared after Rann
of Kutch incident. Of all the places in West Pakistan Lahore was the natural
choice. “I want to reach Lahore before they take Srinagar” were the
strong words of then Prime Minister Shastri to army chief. A threat to its
security could not fail to draw forces to Lahore’s defence, and this could well
remove the threat to Jammu and Akhnur. The offensive was with this limited
objective only.
On 2nd September, just about
thirty-six hours after the Chamb offensive launched by 12th Division, Pakistan
completed the movement of their 7th Division to the Chamb area. On the very same
day, Maj. Gen. Yahya Khan, GOC 7th Div. was given command of this sector
and Maj. Gen. Akhtar Malik was ordered to return to his earlier location
further north. The decision to change commanders in the midst of the Chamb
battle was clearly based on the assumption that the Indian retaliation to an
attack on Akhnur would come in the Pak Occupied Kashmir area in the North and
not against Pakistan territory in the South.
As Pakistan changed horses
in mid-stream, India began to make a last bid to strengthen her crumbling
defences in the Akhnur area. The change of formation slowed down Pakistan’s
advance sufficiently to allow the Indians to consolidate their position. And as
our forces crossed Pakistan borders in Punjab on 6th September at dawn, the
morale of the Indians in the Chamb-Akhnur sector began to recover.
Neither country won the 22
day war. It was inconclusive war. It is equally true that Pakistan lost the war
in that the she failed to win her military and political objectives. Pakistan's
blunder was her over-confidence and arrogant underestimation of its adversary’s
strength and competence. Pakistan having convinced themselves that they would
win the war in a week's time on paper, had put everything they had all at once
in full force their armour, artillery, and air power. With the result Pakistan
army was short of supplies, it was running out of ammunition and had lost
heavily in equipment and trained men. It had to seek help from friendly
countries, Indonesia, China. Pakistan lost most decisive battles of the war-Assal
Uttar in the Khem Karan sector and the tank battle in Sialkot sector. Pakistan
lost half of their American gifted Patton tanks. Their strike power was crippled
and humbled. The psychological impact of loss upon the Pak army and the military
leadership couldn’t be underestimated. To continue to fight under these
circumstances and with principle fighting concentrated in Pakistan would bring
the risk of further heavy losses without immediate hope of gain. Pakistan
finally had to accept conditions for truce which settled none of the issues
which had precipitated war.
It can be concluded from the
course of events that steered the 22 day war, Pakistan had misjudged Indian
psyche to its misadventure. If Pakistan’s army leadership had got hold of the
war plan from Indian army official as reported by Gauhar Ayub, why did they
leave Haji-Pir salient lightly held and then move 12th Division from
South to Chamb sector so as to leave Lahore vulnerable for Indian attack. It is
reported that Zulfikar Ali Bhutto had assured Ayub Khan that Indians would never
violate the Indo-Pakistan border. On what basis Bhutto had given the assurance
would require to be elaborated. These are few unanswered questions, which,
Gauhar Ayub Khan has to throw some light on.
References:
1. Altaf Gauhar was at the
time of conflict, Secretary, Ministry of information & Broadcasting,
Government of Pakistan, who worked closely with Ayub Khan for five and a
half years.
2. Courtesy Times Of
India, Bombay monograph dated November 10th 1965, India Answers
Pakistan by B. G. Verghese.
Source: Kashmir
Sentinel
|